TrackBack strikes back

And of course, Ben of MovableType is not unaware of Pingback:

In current implementations of TrackBack, the user sending the ping must take some action: either by selecting the post he wishes to send a TrackBack ping to via a pulldown menu, or by retrieving the ping URL and pasting it into the entry form. And yes, we agree on the point that transparency is the ultimate goal*.

But note the emphasis on "current implementations"--there is nothing inherent in TrackBack that would prevent an implementation from making it completely transparent.

Interesting. Let's see where he goes with this. He does raise a concern with more automation though:

* (I do worry slightly about the impact of content management systems fetching and scanning every external link in an entry to determine if it's ping-able. But that's not really the issue.)

Hmm - I suppose if a site gets heavily referred to, that's a double-Slashdot-effect? And this investigative process has the potential to add more overhead to the publishing process. But.. hmm, until I see some convincing ConsideredHarmful arguments, I think the flow producing qualities of this sort of thing are worth it.

shortname=ooobic

Archived Comments

  • Hi, You said "Let's see where he goes with this." We're going to add the extracting-links transparency to MT for version 2.5, so that when you post, external links will be extracted, and TrackBack ping URLs auto-discovered and pinged automatically. More details...
  • Sounds very cool! I'd be pinging you back right now, but my webhost seems to be going haywire currently. Thanks for the comment though!
Exodus to JohnCompanies in progress  Previous Pingback may one-up TrackBack Next